Invasiveness versus sustainability : supply chain perceptions of Opuntia ficus-indica in the Maltese food system

Abstract

This research seeks to outline key contradictions in the agricultural uses, cultural values, economic opportunities, and ecological practices associated with the prickly pear cactus, Opuntia ficus-indica (OFI). Understanding contradictions in perspectives on invasive species like OFI aids in informing policy surrounding the environmental management of such species and contributes towards global research of invasive-food system integration, which is becoming increasingly important as climate change threatens traditional agricultural systems. This project analyzes necessary trade-offs associated with managing OFI in Malta through supply chain perceptions and valuation in primary markets, and consumer-side interviews in informal markets to capture perceptions and uses of the prickly pear cactus. Alongside a policy and literature review on historic and current uses, markets, and management practices, these data were analyzed through reflexive thematic analysis to create themes. Three major findings emerged from these analyses: contradictions between perceived nativeness and nonnative origins; nuanced views of plant classification impacted by cultural and food systems associations; and limited commercial development and institutional support despite OFI's climate resilience. A SWOT analysis was then used to evaluate potential futures for OFI. These findings presented three key pathways for OFI: increased investment, continuing current practices, and increased environmental regulation. These findings ultimately suggest that the role of OFI must be understood by the sum of its functions, as an environmental concern, agricultural resource, commercial product, and a cultural symbol. Any pathways for OFI are dependent on how stakeholders weigh trade-offs between these functions.