Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: https://www.um.edu.mt/library/oar/handle/123456789/149363
Title: Truth’s contamination : the impact of human errors on forensic investigations
Authors: Ben Ismail, Sara (2026)
Keywords: Crime laboratories
Evidence, Criminal
Criminal justice, Administration of
Criminal investigation
Issue Date: 2026
Citation: Ben Ismail, S. (2026). Truth’s contamination: the impact of human errors on forensic investigations (Bachelor's dissertation).
Abstract: This dissertation examines how human error contributes to contamination within forensic investigations and explores the implications this has for the reliability of forensic evidence. The study was motivated by the recognition that forensic science, although widely regarded as objective and scientifically grounded, remains vulnerable to mistakes that occur during the collection, preservation, and interpretation of physical traces. Contamination poses a significant threat to evidential integrity, and understanding how it arises is essential for ensuring fairness and accuracy within the criminal justice system. To investigate this issue, the research adopted a qualitative design that combined case study analysis with interviews from forensic practitioners. The cases of Brandon Mayfield and Lukis Anderson were selected because they clearly demonstrate how both cognitive and physical contamination can distort investigative reasoning and contribute to wrongful arrests. These cases were examined alongside practitioner accounts to provide a deeper understanding of how contamination occurs in real investigative settings and how human behaviour shapes forensic outcomes. The findings indicate that contamination is influenced by a combination of operational pressures, environmental conditions, communication challenges, and cognitive factors. Practitioners described preventive measures such as personal protective equipment, scene control, and careful packaging, yet acknowledged that these safeguards are not always applied consistently. External contributors, particularly first responders and investigators, were frequently identified as sources of contamination, while internal pressures such as fatigue and workload were recognised as factors that affect attention to detail. These results suggest that contamination cannot be addressed solely through technical procedures. Instead, it requires continuous training, stronger communication between investigative personnel, and organisational support that recognises the human factors involved. The study concludes that improving awareness, refining protocols, and strengthening collaboration across investigative roles are essential steps toward enhancing the reliability of forensic evidence and supporting the pursuit of justice.
Description: B.A. (Hons) Criminology(Melit.)
URI: https://www.um.edu.mt/library/oar/handle/123456789/149363
Appears in Collections:Dissertations - FacSoW - 2026
Dissertations - FacSoWCri - 2026

Files in This Item:
File Description SizeFormat 
2608SWBCRM301105080943_1.PDF
  Restricted Access
1.6 MBAdobe PDFView/Open Request a copy


Items in OAR@UM are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.